The Jolly Roger Review | Once Upon a Time Season 3, Episode 17

The Jolly Roger Review | Once Upon a Time Season 3, Episode 17 photo 0 Info

I would certainly offer anything to take it back, to make points right.

Captain Hook

Starring Ginnifer Goodwin, Jennifer Morrison, Lana Parrilla, Josh Dallas, Emilie de Ravin, Colin O’Donoghue, and also Jared S. Gilmore.


Season 3Episode 17: The Playful Roger

The Jolly Roger Review | Once Upon a Time Season 3, Episode 17 photo 1

Captain Hook’s depiction since his introduction has been one of the much more exciting. His standing as an ethically loose anti-hero definitely makes him a fascinating personality to watch, and also the various other primary Hook-centric episode, “Good Type” assisted to cement him primarily as a man of honour, whose roguish pirate persona remained in reality a front in his attempt to rebel against the dishonesty of his king. Throughout his communications with Emma Swan, however, we have seen this veneer gradually peel away to reveal the sides of the honourable, good natured and also open hearted Killian Jones. His very early suggestive flirting with Emma to control her when they were working against each various other has actually given way to a deeply earnest and also sincere confession of his feelings towards her. His connection to other personalities, such as Henry and Neal even more cements the suggestion that Hook is an unlike the traditional harsh pirate from the source product.

With this episode, we take on the conflict that Hook experiences in changing back to his old existence when cursed back to the Enchanted Forest. Unlike Regina and also the other fairytale personalities who remain united, Hook has no ties to this team and also ventures off on his own. In a similar way to Regina going to pieces without Henry, Hook is in a similar way shed without Emma as well as promptly slides back right into his old routines as a pirate. He really feels the pressure to meet his old name in order to persuade those in the Enchanted Woodland that he hasn’t altered through his organization with the Charmings, even causing him settling a woman of the street to make sure that his crew mates don’t understand that he hasn’t slept with her.

This dispute comes to a head when Hook exists with an option either to conserve Prince Eric or to restore the Playful Roger. He chooses the latter, completely spoiling Ariel’s pleased ending at the same time. With this tale, we have actually seen Hook be cagey concerning his previous year in the Enchanted Woodland as well as here we can plainly see why. He is deeply embarrassed of his activities right here as well as his slip back right into his old routine, to the level where he feels forced to admit to Ariel about his transgressions.

While this episode shows up tangential, it is held up by a commanding performance by Colin O’Donoghue. He takes care of to pay his pining and love for Emma without his character stumbling upon as needy or pitiful, and scenes including him continue to be a delight. This episode additionally features the glorious return of Ariel, that continues to be incredibly endearing throughout her stories.

The Jolly Roger Review | Once Upon a Time Season 3, Episode 17 photo 2

The spin ending that Zelena has, in fact, disguised herself as Ariel was completely unforeseen and has certainly made a compelling story relocating forwards. The fact that Hook and also Emma are apparently on a romantic clash has placed Hook in a huge predicament, either to kiss Emma as well as to strip her of her powers or to be responsible for the deaths of those around her, including Henry. It’s absolutely a scenario that Hook can not win. He spends the whole episode making use of the Cheerful Roger as an alternative for Emma and also now that he has admitted his love aloud, he locates himself even more than ever before from her by the close of the episode. Right here’s really hoping that Hook can find his way out of the issue faster instead of later.

This episode likewise has some fascinating subplots. A rather humorous one is Snow and also Enchanting attempting to prove to Henry, as well as undoubtedly to themselves, that they are fun– a splendidly on-the-nose plot considering the feelings of the huge majority of the target market. Scenes with Snow as well as Charming are never as fun as the ones with Regina or Rumple. There’s something much more fascinating regarding anti-heroes. Somewhere else, Regina begins teaching Emma to make use of magic, which highlights for us simply how much of an effective risk Emma can be in the future.

It isn’t without its rational problems. Zelena’s strategy to neutralise Emma appears ahead out of no place, considering we have never ever before heard Emma’s name appeared of her mouth. If Emma is truly such a substantial danger to Zelena, after that why really did not she make some moves to quit her before now? Likewise, why did she curse everybody back to Storybrooke? If they had actually remained in the Enchanted Forest with Emma’s memories still removed, after that Zelena would certainly’ve been cost-free to enact her bad masterplan.

In other words

  • In The Year That Time Forgot, Ariel seeks out Hook to help her find Royal prince Eric who has actually been kidnapped by Black Beard on board the Playful Roger.
  • Hook, Smee as well as Ariel choose Black Beard as well as Hook duels him, yet inevitably chooses acquiring his ship over finding Ariel’s real love.
  • In Storybrooke, Ariel turns up searching for Eric as well as Hook is enlisted to help the operation.
  • It appears that all is lost, bring about Hook admitting what he did to Ariel.
  • It ends up that Ariel was in truth Zelena in disguise, forcing Hook to admit his true love for Emma to make sure that Zelena could curse his kiss and also strip away Emma’s powers.

Other thoughts

  • It’s weird exactly how uniquely worried the personalities are about Henry, and yet they let him go to the store by himself at the start of the episode as if there isn’t a homicidal witch on the loose.
  • Regina’s comments concerning infant components in remedies was equivalent parts entertaining and also terrifying.
  • Snow’s stress over “Nobody’s spotted Zelena or Rumple since the duel! We ought to determine what they depend on and quit them!” makes complete feeling until Regina shows that the duel between her and Zelena just took place the previous evening. Chill out, Snow. Not seeing somebody over night is not cause to stress. And if you were mosting likely to stress you would certainly have done it prior to resting.
  • Why would certainly Captivating think that almost killing Henry would certainly make him fun? Overcompensating.
  • Why is no one shielding Belle? All of the others are within a security spell at Snow’s house, yet they just leave Belle to fend for herself in Gold’s shop? Speaking of which, whatever occurred to her task at the collection?
  • Regina’s face when she assumes she’s mistakenly eliminated Emma was disarmingly amusing.
  • The most strange minute of the episode is most likely when Black Beard’s crew are viewing Hook handle the evil pirate as well as a sheet drops in front of them. Instead of grabbing the sheet as well as peering around it, the staff apparently stand on the opposite side in total silence. That must have been entertaining watching.
  • Regina’s outrage, and also subsequent uncomfortable having fun off, at Henry driving the vehicle was invaluable.
  • Ariel’s story has actually been nicely involved a bow, which is an embarassment as she is a satisfying personality, yet at the very least it’s one much less repeating personality for the show to need to handle.
  • It’s beautiful that Regina ultimately got that family members meal with Henry as well as the Charmings, after she had not been welcomed early in Season 2.
  • Henry is absolutely so much a lot more likeable as an average adolescent boy than he was as a believer. Obviously he will eventually restore his memories, but this plot has actually most definitely done a lot in the means of developing the character to match Jared Gilmore’s real age.
  • Why is it that Emma is such a danger to Zelena? Is she the Saviour for this curse as well? Is she able to damage this and also avoid Zelena’s story?


A character-driven episode for one of the extra complex as well as exciting personalities in the show, with a game-changing as well as unscrupulous spin included for good action.

You can watch Once Seasons 1– 7 on Netflix. It is likewise offered on residence media and various other digital systems for purchase or rent.

Rate article